
Trisha Brown, Sikkema Jenkins & Co., New York, Dec. 9, 2011 – Jan. 25, 2012
Drawings by pioneer postmodern dancer and choreographer Trisha Brown are the main feature of her second solo show at Sikkema Jenkins & Co. in Chelsea. Part of a longtime engagement with mark-marking adjunct to her dance practice, selections from Brown’s series “It’s a Draw” document the movements of her feet as she dances on paper.[i] Like her Judson Church colleague Yvonne Rainer’s recent book of poems,[ii] Brown’s drawings address a contemporary audience accustomed to intergenre code-switching. Yet critiques of dilettantism may be quick on the heels of the de-specialized, often impetuous forays into new disciplines endemic in today’s creative community. As Claire Bishop argues in a recent essay, an artist’s decision to reject the specific modes of production of his/her training for others, or de-skilling, “always requires a re-skilling if it is to convince us that it is more than simply amateur. On the most basic level, this re-skilling is rhetorical: being able to account for, persuasively narrate, and even theorize one’s disciplinary unraveling.”[iii] How effectively can Brown’s drawings hold their own as integrated formal compositions in a visual art context? Is their significance rather derivative of the ephemeral performances they index? Are Brown’s maneuvers between media limber enough for her drawings to withstand critique as objects?
Lining the walls of Sikkema Jenkins & Co. are 11 large drawings, each approximately 130 by 107 inches. As she moves atop paper flush with the floor, an oil pastel or piece of charcoal poised between Brown’s toes inscribes her perambulations. Emerging as languid arcs, tight whorls, isolated toe-touch daubs, heel scuffs, and occasional foot and fingerprints, incidental strokes map Brown’s contact with the ground, the moments between steps or leaps. A spectrum of rhythmic and tonal details can be teased out through reading the traces of her motions—light, sprawling and sparse; dense and angular—a vigorous shift even ripping the paper substrate in one case.

Trisha Brown, Untitled (Montpellier), 2002. Charcoal on paper, 130 x 106.75 inches. © Trisha Brown; Courtesy of Sikkema Jenkins & Co., New York.
Such a detail underscores Brown’s attention to positioning along vertical and horizontal axes—scuff marks become gestural as the drawings are transported from floor to wall, reorienting the viewer’s relationship to the performance, just as Brown’s infamous 1970 piece Man Walking Down the Side of a Building accomplished the exact inverse for dance. A subtle counterpart is Brown’s 1998 video Shot Backstage, exhibited alongside the drawings, in which the choreographer videotaped her company’s performance from a lateral vantage between the stage curtains, perpendicular to the audience’s perspective.
In a series of short reflections which annotate cropped “It’s a Draw” works in Walker Art Center’s 2008 exhibition catalogue, Brown verbally reconstructs her movements from their visual vestiges. Of a particularly dark helical form she comments: “It felt like tar on my foot, and turning, and trying to create white striations also.”[iv] One questions whether these notes are a retrospective analysis of the traces, or expose a precedent formal intention—did Brown’s visual discretion bear upon her dancing as the drawings emerged or were they composed objectively from a continuous performance? Were her movements circumscribed by the paper’s dimensions, or did she allow transgressions of its boundaries? It is perhaps this very probing of motives—which comes first, the drawing or the dance?—that gives the work a generative discursive strength. In Brown’s drawings the two contexts are so precisely overlaid, the methodologies so confounded, that these ambiguities will remain active and suspended, making their viewing an engaging aesthetic and intellectual experience. Instead of grasping for a new context altogether, Brown’s drawings reapply and challenge her primary practice in a new medium, their very process sketching the frictions of the transfer. -Kaegan Sparks, Special Events Associate
____________________________________
[i] Work from “It’s a Draw” is also pivotal to curator Helen Molesworth’s current exhibition at the Institute of Contemporary Art, Boston, Dance/Draw.
[ii] Rainer, Yvonne. Poems. New York: Badlands Unlimited, 2011.
[iii] Bishop, Claire. “UNHAPPY DAYS IN THE ART WORLD? De-skilling Theater, Re-skilling Performance.” The Brooklyn Rail December 2011/January 2012: http://www.brooklynrail.org/2011/12/art/unhappy-days-in-the-art-worldde-skilling-theater-re-skilling-performance
[iv] Bither, Philip, Trisha Brown, and Peter Eleey. Trisha Brown: So That the Audience Does Not Know Whether I Have Stopped Dancing. Minneapolis: Walker Art Center, 2008.